Please help me choose the best cropped version of the two photos

MNCR M-1 8297 @ Spuyten Duyvil (Hudson Line). Photo taken by Brian Weinberg, 11/7/2005.
MNCR M-1 8297 @ Spuyten Duyvil (Hudson Line). Photo taken by Brian Weinberg, 11/7/2005.
MNCR M-1 8297 @ Spuyten Duyvil (Hudson Line). Photo taken by Brian Weinberg, 11/7/2005.
MNCR M-1 8297 @ Spuyten Duyvil (Hudson Line). Photo taken by Brian Weinberg, 11/7/2005.
MNCR M-1 8297 @ Spuyten Duyvil (Hudson Line). Photo taken by Brian Weinberg, 11/7/2005.
MNCR M-1 8297 @ Spuyten Duyvil (Hudson Line). Photo taken by Brian Weinberg, 11/7/2005.